Not all book clubs are the same. Nor should they be. Every book club has something different to offer. It could be how often books are selected or who picks them to themes or genres within the club. Many book clubs have an intention around one or more of these topics. Some may treat intentions more like rules. What we’ve seen from experience, and will explore in reviewing the top 5 book clubs, is where intention and flexibility may lead to a club’s longevity or success.

 

Whether you’re starting a book club, looking for one to join or your book club could use a refresh, reviewing different book clubs can be a great exercise. It can help start your own book club or inform your decision to participate in one. Reviewing other book clubs can also inform and provide ideas to bring to your own book club.

 

Here we keep up with the top 5 most popular book clubs, which are currently:

 

Reese’s Book Club

Oprah’s Book Club

Our Shared Shelf

Between Two Books

Read with Jenna

 

The top 5 book clubs on Book Club Review are primarily determined by how many members or participants they have and how long they have been around.

 

Taking a look at how other book clubs are running and functioning can help you choose one to join, find a place to start your own book club and offer your own book club fresh ideas including reading recommendations, selection frequency, selection genres and themes and even who selects the book.